Renowned British Philosopher Sir Isaiah Berlin, a proud secular Jew, warns us that our need for ideal solutions is often beyond our reach and in fact dangerous.
I believe…that some of the ultimate values by which men live cannot be reconciled or combined, not just for practical reasons, but in principle, conceptually….You cannot combine full liberty with full equality—full liberty for the wolves cannot be combined with full liberty for the sheep. Justice and mercy, knowledge and happiness can collide….the idea of a perfect solution of human problems—of how to live—cannot be coherently conceived….there is no avoiding compromises; they are bound to be made: the very worst can be averted by trade-offs. So much for this, so much for that….How much justice, how much mercy? How much kindness, how much truth?….the idea of some ultimate solution of all our problems is incoherent….All fanatical belief in the possibility of a final solution, reached no matter how, cannot but lead to suffering, misery, blood, terrible oppression.(1)
Powerful Orthodox rabbis who deal with the crisis of conversion in the State of Israel had better take these words to heart.
If we do not act quickly, growing assimilation will not only overwhelm the Jewish character of the State of Israel but actually undermine its very existence and security. Nearly 400,000 Russian legal residents, of Jewish descent but halachically not Jewish, could unwittingly bring an end to the Jewish state within the next 50 to 100 years, once their non-Jewish children marry into Jewish families. While it is true that if their sons marry Jewish women their children will be Jewish, this is far from a healthy option. The conversion issue is not just a halachic problem but also a sociological one. It is highly undesirable for so many people of Jewish descent to ultimately remain non-Jews. It will create serious social difficulties, including discrimination and feelings of rejection, which can easily undermine a society that is already dealing with enough problems.
Unresolved issues accumulate and inevitably create catastrophes. Many people see them coming, but like sleepers in the midst of a nightmare, they do nothing because the nightmare paralyzes them.
While much more must be done to inspire people to become Jewish and observe Halacha — through a welcoming atmosphere, exciting and convincing seminars, invitations to our homes and other means, as I pointed out last week (2) — demanding of people to observe all of the commandments is too much for many of them.
Here is where we need to take notice of Sir Isaiah Berlin’s warning. There are no perfect solutions. A far-reaching compromise and an ideological trade-off will be necessary. We must choose between apriori halachic standards — only converting people who are prepared to live according to Halacha, consequently causing a flood of assimilation in the State of Israel and endangering its existence as well as the security of millions of Jews — or using every lenient halachic view to prevent that.
It will be necessary to establish a halachic ruling and to admit that the survival of the State of Israel overrules the need for halachic commitment on an individual level. However painful, we are not permitted to apply the conventional standards of conversion as stated in our traditional sources, since these sources never imagined a modern Jewish State that would absorb nearly 400,000 non-Jews of Jewish descent. (3) It would be a colossal mistake to apply the strict halachic ruling, constituting a transgression of the very Halacha to which we are committed. The halachic need to convert these people, no matter what, is not the lenient ruling but in fact the stricter one.
Instead of waiting until the candidates are ready to take on Jewish law, and only then converting them, we should first convert them, make them feel comfortable, invite them to our homes and synagogues, and slowly introduce them to Jewish religious values and Halacha. This should be done by way of gentle persuasion and love, with no coercion whatsoever. We must give them the option of making their own choices, introducing them to a ladder of observance that they can climb at their own pace and within their own abilities. This will be much more effective than making all sorts of preconditions, which for the most part are counterproductive.
Let’s tell them that it would be great if they would start observing some biblical laws and that there’s no need for them to observe all rabbinical laws. Let it be optional. We can inform them about the many minority opinions in the Talmud that may be more applicable to them and will speak more to their hearts. When they are ready for it, they may introduce their own laws and practices and decide how to observe Shabbat while making use of tradition. Let us suggest that saying Shema Yisrael in the morning and evening is a major accomplishment; putting on tefillin once in a while is a most meaningful undertaking; and wearing a kippah all the time is not even a halacha but a beautiful and pious act (4). Let them make their own brachot if they want, or just say “Wow” before they eat and “Thanks” after they are satisfied (5). Let them use their creative imagination and feel that they are gradually building their own Judaism and seeing its wonders. Slowly, some of them will discern the wisdom of the Sages and introduce more of rabbinical law in their lives. They will do it willingly, out of a sincere desire to be part of this great tradition.
It is high time the rabbis realize that the very standing of Halacha is at stake. If it cannot find a realistic solution to the conversion problem, it will become less and less significant in the eyes of Jews the world over. In fact, it will prove that contemporary Halacha has run its course. Ultimately, it will lose its influence on our young people. It is not only the survival of Jews that is at stake but also the survival of Halacha itself.
Most important to remember is that kabbalat hamitzvot (acceptance of the commandments) is not the only issue as far as conversion is concerned. Judaism is much more than just Halacha. The first convert and Jew, Avraham, was only asked to observe a few of the commandments, such as circumcision. An incubation period was required to allow for an embryonic form of Judaism, which was to develop slowly and be solidified at Sinai with the giving of the Torah. In this time frame, the great moral–religious foundations of Judaism and the conditions for creating the Jewish nation were shaped. Only afterward was it possible to introduce the world of mitzvot and Halacha. We should allow potential converts this option to slowly work their way up to Sinai. And if they will not arrive at this momentous hour, we should be pleased that they have cast their fate with our people. Every mitzvah the convert does is done as a Jew, and that in itself is a great accomplishment (6). We can then hope that the convert’s child will observe many more commandments.
At the same time we should not forget that sole adherence to the law can actually do great harm. Every legal system works in categories of right and wrong, lawful and unlawful. But life itself is much more than any law can ever sustain or cover – even Divine law. There is a narrative that slips through the net of the law and rises above it. A nation with a mission must be constantly aware that sometimes it has to break the law so as to allow the spirit of the law and its ultimate goal to have the upper hand.
While far from ideal from a religious or conventional halachic point of view, it may be necessary to introduce mass conversion (7) as the only option to overcome the impending danger of countless mixed marriages in Israel, which will otherwise break the backbone of the Jewish state. Inclusiveness is now the order of the day.
We must remind ourselves that since the State of Israel was established, our future is in our own hands. Never have we had such freedom to do whatever we want when it comes to our own destiny. No one can stop us from doing what needs to be done. This is unprecedented in the last 2,000 years of Jewish history. All that is required is courage.
This is true about Halacha as well. It is up to the leading Orthodox rabbis to realize this and show us the way. Whether they like it or not, ultimately they will be forced to take drastic steps and change their attitude toward the issue of conversion in the State of Israel. The only question is how many casualties will there be before they come around. They should be most careful not to extend their imprimatur after the fact.
“The paradox of courage is that a man must be a little careless of his life even in order to keep it,” said English author G. K. Chesterton.
- Ramin Jahanbegloo, Conversations with Isaiah Berlin (London: Halban Publishers, 2007) pp.142-143.
- Thoughts to Ponder 454: “Conversion and Annie Fischer’s Interpretation of Shumann’s Klavierkonzert in A Minor.”
- See Rabbi Benzion Uziel, former Sephardic Chief Rabbi of Israel, Piskei Uziel, 23.
- See Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 8:6, Biur HaGra.
- See the minority opinion in Brachot
- Chief Rabbi Benzion Uziel, Mishpetei Uziel, Yoreh Dei’ah, vol. 1, no. 58.
- See famous Rabbi Yoel Bin-Nun in Eretz Acheret, pp. 68-69.
For this and other essays of Nathan Lopes Cardozo in Times of Israel, see: http://blogs.timesofisrael.
Questions to Ponder from the David Cardozo Think Tank:
The essay argues for relaxing the current stringent conversion standards in order to avert a grave danger to Jews and the Jewish state. The larger question is: Are present-day halachic stringencies, including conversion standards, in and of themselves out of line with “authentic” Jewish thought and insight (regardless of their impact, negative or otherwise, on the fabric and security of Jewish life in Israel)?
In at least some cases, could the disinclination of converts to follow Halacha in all its details indicate a healthy alertness to deficiencies in contemporary Halacha, rather than a psycho-spiritual misalignment with the Jewish tradition, which needs to be rectified?
Do you think that a settled body of Halacha that can and should be adhered to by all Jews is:
- Indispensable to the health of the Jewish tradition?
- Optimal but not indispensable?
- Something that the Jewish tradition should aspire to outgrow?
Should converts have a special dispensation to be lenient in their adherence to Halacha? Notwithstanding that, should there also be an affirmation that their adherence to Halacha is suspended only because the Halacha is in disrepair? Would this be a way to allow converts to be lenient in their observance while still accepting the full authority of Halacha?
The Talmud (Bechorot 30b) suggests that converts should not be accepted until they undertake to adhere to every minor detail of the Halacha – but were there fewer details to adhere to then than today, and should this be taken into account?
Is there a way to rectify the dysfunction in the conversion regime without an open acknowledgement on the part of the conversion authorities that there are deficiencies, that it is a necessity that they be rectified, and that it is a defining responsibility of the authorities that this be done?
– See more at: http://cardozoacademy.org/current-thought-to-ponder-by-rabbi-lopes-cardozo/courage-rabbis-courage-the-need-for-mass-conversion-ttp-455/#sthash.lrkeXaiP.dpuf
Ada Prins says
I do agree,what you wrote about conversion.
It is far more important to see and feel the warmth and the friendly way Jews have together for a men or woman who want to convert first.
What I am concerned for that is the big gap between the different orthodox rabbies.And the Halacha that is more and more severe.
It is better to show kindness to every Jew,secular,reform,conservative or ultra Orthodox.especially for converts who have always the courage to become Jewish.
I saw the movie A Kippah in the Caribbean,a quest for Jewish Caribbean identity.
This was an very interesting Dutch movie.English undertitled,about the history of the Jews in Suriname and the Dutch Antilles.
What I learned was that it is a small community,with not so much rules,but very warm for everybody who visits their community.
And Jews,catholics,Cristians and Moslims could get along very well.
For Israel now it is very important that every Jew and convert is one soul.
And that is what every Orthodox rabbi have to learn.
We wish you a very sweet and Healty Rosh Hashana en we are in Jerusalem from 24 september until 13 october.